Whatta Man Special Edition – Best of 2012 {Part 2}


You might remember from last week that we are capping off the year with the Ultimate Whatta Man Competition.

We have divided a year’s worth of winners into two posts. The two winners will then go head to head and one will win the prize for Ultimate Hottie of 2012.

Looks like the Jan – June winner is Ian Somerhottie. I mean…Ian Somerholder.

So…here are the July – December winners. Let’s pick a good one — Ian is hot!!

I know that it’s a tough job, being so superficial. But I’m asking you to sacrifice your morals just this once.

Okay, who are we fooling. Just vote and love every second of it!!


Joe Maganiello.  He  won the Magic Mike Edition months after winning the True Blood Edition.  He’s a hottie, alright.

Jason Segal.  He won the How I Met Your Mother Edition.  He’s scruffy and sweet.

Andrew Garfield.  The number one Spider Man.  Pretty sure his accent sealed the deal.

Joseph Gordon Levitt.  Your favorite quirky guy.   He beat John Krasinski, which makes my heart cry.

Ryan Lochte.  He pees in the pool.  You don’t mind.

Tom Hardy.  Shelly kinda wants to marry him.  So do you.

N’Sync.  Justin MADE them, lets face it.

Nathan Fillion.  I think he’s the definition of “cult like following”.  Women are crazy about him!

One Direction. Young, but not TOO young.


Prince Harry.  His funny business in Vegas just made him even cuter.

NKOTB.  Hottest boy band ever.  Man, we’re old.

Liam Neeson.  He beat Harrison Ford in the Old Dude Action Star edition.

Rob Lowe.  He’s your favorite Parks and Rec hottie.  But I’m still not convinced that raisins are nature’s candy.

George Stephanopoulos.   You begrudgingly named him your favorite Morning Show Dude.

Jackson Avery.  He beat Alex Karev.  Not surprised.

Noel.  He beat Ben in the Felicity Edition.  Shelly demanded a recount.  I cheered and knew that all was right with the world.

Bobby Flay.  He can cook us dinner any day.

Pacey.  He beat Dawson in the biggest NO DUH everrrrrrrr.


James McAvoy.  He beat James Franco.  Color me SHOCKED!!

Jake Gyllenhaal.  He is your favorite Taylor Swift ex.  Can’t say that I blame you…John Mayer is a moron.

Luke Bryan.  He can sing us sweet country music any day.

Gabriel Aubrey.  His black eye did nothing to diminish his hottness in your eyes.


Colin Firth.  He won the Love, Actually edition, but I think Pride and Predjudice is what REALLY sealed the deal.

Maks.  He beat Derek.  You like a bad boy, I get it.

Alex O’Loughlin.  You’re Hawaii 5 OH SO CRAZY about him.  (Yes, I just went there.  SO??)


Okay, chickies…that’s it for 2012!!  Who is going to go against Ian Somerholder as Whatta Man of the Year??


Can’t wait to see your votes!!

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.


  1. 1

    “He beat John Krasinski, which makes my heart cry.” Haha…love.

    I still can’t get over the fact that Jon Bon Jovi beat Jon Hamm. That made MY heart cry.

  2. 2
    Norma says:

    Why must you torture us week after week after week? How can one choose? And what do we win? These men never call, never write, never show up at my house. But I’ll do what I must. I mean it’s not like we can just leave 2012 hanging, can we.

    I vote Alex O’Loughlin. He’s so yummy. But where’s Hugh Jackman in all of this? I demand a recount!

  3. 3
    Mary Beth P says:

    ~ Nathan Fillion

  4. 4
    Holly says:

    Nathan Fillion!

  5. 5
    Maggie says:

    Joe Maganiello gets my vote for sure!

  6. 6
    Kaia says:

    No contest, Nathan Fillion for the win!

  7. 7
    Tammy T says:

    Nathan Fillion!

  8. 8
    Leslie says:

    Joe Maganiello!!

  9. 9
    Sarah E says:

    Gotta go with my fave quirky guy, JGL!

  10. 10
    Victoria says:

    Jason Segel!!! No wait, Nathan Fillion…no wait…argh!

    Going with my initial pick…Jason Segel.

  11. 11
    Marie M.C. says:

    Joseph Gorden Levitt, although Colin Firth . . . well either one of theses men (including Hugh Jackman) can leave his shoes under my bed . . . anytime.

  12. 12
    Colene says:

    Oh, c’mon, no contest, Nathan Fillion!! You can’t beat a handsome geek :) And especially someone who you know will keep you laughing long after all the smooches.

  13. 13
    Shelly says:

    James McAvoy!

  14. 14
    Dawn says:

    ~Joe Maganiello

  15. 15
    Ruth D says:

    Toss up between Mr Darcy and the Irish but I have to go with Mr Darcy. He’s been my secret crush forever.
    Ok, so I’m old.

  16. 16
    Tamara M. says:

    Alex O’Loughlin

  17. 17
    Jan says:

    Alex O’Loughlin – yum! :-)

  18. 18
  19. 19
    Melissa says:

    Jackson Avery

  20. 20
  21. 21
    Amy says:

    Alex O’Loughlin:)

  22. 22
    capa says:

    Fillion or Neeson… or….
    No, Fillion. Quirks, laughs and all. Since I found out he can sew and weld there’s no contest in my heart, really.

  23. 23
    Mona says:

    Rob Lowe

  24. 24
    Julie says:

    Jackson Avery :)

  25. 25
    keri wamboldt says:

    Ahhhh! Nathan Fillion or Alex O’Laughlin, damn!
    Well he’ll always be my captain, Nathan Fillion for the win!!

  26. 26
    Elizabeth says:

    Oh my! I hate to play favorites when there are so many worthy hotties up there but my ♥ goes to Nathan Fillion!

  27. 27
    Donna says:

    Alex O’Loughlin

  28. 28
    brandi says:

    First, i’m just sad that Ian is in this at all. he looks like he needs a shower, but not in a hot way. gross. and he just creeps me out….like he could easily be a stalker.

    I say JGL!! LOVE him. He’s funny, smart, and dresses well.

  29. 29
    Kimberly says:

    Nathan Fillion. He’s dashingly cute, funny, he can sing, and then there’s… well… his hammer. LOL

  30. 30
    Jennifer says:

    Choices, choices, choices… LOVE Nathan Fillion in Castle so he’ll get my vote. BUT it was a close decision between him and Luke Bryan cause I wouldn’t mind singing him “Shake it for me boy, shake for me boy. Shake it for me”!

  31. 31
    Elizabeth Frometa says:

    I seem to be the only one, but my vote goes to Tom Hardy!

  32. 32
    Vicki P. says:

    Alex O’Loughlin is my pick but I think I agree with Shel about Tom Hardy.

  33. 33
  34. 34
    cindy says:

    Alex O’Loughlin

  35. 35
    Nicki says:

    Tom Hardy!

  36. 36
    Kelly W. says:

    Rob Lowe!

  37. 37
    Tina says:

    I never comment but had to on this one. Tom Hardy gets my vote. Earlier this year I was reading an article about him. He overcame a drug addiction and said his life could have went either way but he got things turned around. Now he works with other people trying to do the same thing. As if he was not sexy enough, that sealed the deal for me.

  38. 38
    Jen Grimm says:

    Oh so many choices…Rob Lowe has awesome eyes, Jake Gyllenhaal is scruffy sexy, Ales O’ Loughlin is just all out sexy, butttttt the hottest of them all is that bad boy Maks! He can dance my way any day or night 24/7!!!!!

  39. 39
    Courtney B @ The Messy Texan says:

    Nathan Fillion!

  40. 40
  41. 41
    Erin F. says:

    Oh, man. You are making this very difficult for me by putting Alcide and Jake in the same contest!! I will have to stay true to my man though, and go with Jake Gyllenhaal. :)

  42. 42
    aryn says:

    Nathan Fillion, Captain Tightpants, if you will.

  43. 43
    Jessica D says:

    Im going with James McAvoy… I just love his normal boy looks with a hot ass heck body… if Wanted can be any judge…

  44. 44
    Lauren says:

    Part 2 is way easier. I think part one was stacked. I’m going JGL first and tom hardy 2nd.

  45. 45
    dawne says:

    rob lowe :)

  46. 46
    Heather says:

    Nathan Fillion!

  47. 47
    mallory says:

    Alex O’Laughlin!

  48. 48
    Beth says:

    Alex O’Loughlin

  49. 49
    Amanda says:

    Alex O’Loughlin, although Jackson Avery is a close second just due to his amazing eyes alone… although, I hate him with hair in the newer episodes.

Speak Your Mind